+44 (0) 20 7329 1300

Artful Plant: When Capital Allowances may be Claimed on a Painting

In 1776 Sir Joshua Reynolds painted a portrait later purchased by the 5th Earl of Carlisle.  The painting was taken for display at the family seat at Castle Howard in Yorkshire where for the next 200 years it remained until being sold for over £9m in 2001 on behalf of the late Lord Howard.

The recent Court of Appeal decision in HMRC v The Executors of Lord Howard of Henderskelfe confirmed that this painting was plant and therefore was a wasting asset exempt from capital gains tax.  The facts of this case neatly illustrate the tests used to decide when decorative assets can be plant and so qualify for capital allowances.

 

As background, established case law provides two tests that can indicate when an asset is plant;

 

  • Function test: The asset needs to perform some active function and be used in the normal course of a business
  • Permanence test: The asset needs to be used on an ongoing basis within the business as opposed to being an item of trading stock intended to be held only until it can be sold on.

 

The painting was displayed at Castle Howard being one of the main attractions for visitors since 1952 when the Castle was first opened to the public.  The Executors used these facts to argue the above two tests were met and that the painting was clearly a permanent piece of the ‘business apparatus.’  HMRC unsurprisingly took issue with this but the Court of Appeal held the painting was definitely and actively used for promotion of the trade.  This could have been for example, in the company’s material marketing the Castle and brochures for visitors.

 

While HMRCs arguments relating to the permanence test suggested the lack of formal agreement between the legal owner of the painting and the company using it in their trade for display at Castle Howard meant it could not be plant.  This is because the painting could have been removed at any time though the facts did not support this position.

 

Another point used by HMRC was that the painting was not plant in the hands of the Executors who owned it.  Helpfully the Court held that an asset could not be plant in the hands of a person using it for business purposes while at the same time not being plant in the hands of its owner.

England1_144

This case related to a painting which is a chattel for tax purposes being ‘tangible moveable property.’ By the way, it is worth noting the tests used above also apply to determine when an asset is plant where the decorative assets are not moveable, for example, mosaics, murals and sculptures or feature walls hotels or restaurants that are also part of fabric of the building itself ratified in the case CIR v Scottish & Newcastle Breweries Ltd.

 

HMRC will accept paintings may qualify for capital allowances if they improve the ambience in trades where ‘atmosphere’ could be said to improve custom.  So this is clearly more relevant to trade related properties like restaurants and hotels or client facing areas in offices rather than general office areas where customers may never visit.  HMRC guidance frames it in terms of trades where ‘selling atmosphere is part of the business.’

 

HMRC may still choose to challenge cases where capital allowances are claimed on high value paintings within non trade related property and are not on display to the public.  Their internal guidance says tax inspectors should only accept items of decor as plant if the:

 

  • trade involves the creation of atmosphere/ambience and in effect the sale of that ambience to its customers, and the
  • items on which plant or machinery allowances are claimed were specially chosen to create the atmosphere that the taxpayer is trying to sell.

 

The guidance specifically gives the example of a painting on an accountant’s office wall that is owned by the accountant not being plant because selling atmosphere is not part of an accountants business.  However, times have moved on since this guidance was written and it is now normal for paintings to be found in a modern office environment intended to promote brand values, create ambience for visiting clients and for staff wellbeing for example.

 

So a practical approach in more everyday situations where the value of paintings or decorative plant items are of much lower values would be to consider these items as purchased as part of the working plant and machinery of the business, particularly if they are on display in the business rather than held in storage, despite the HMRCs guidance.  Furthermore, any painting worth less than £6,000 will be seen as a chattel for CGT purposes by HMRC and so exempt.  Chattels are tangible moveable property and where used in a business will also likely be plant for capital allowances purposes.

 

Back to News

OTHER NEWS

20170719_133055

Lovell Consulting Capital Allowances Student Prize Winner 2017

Lovell Coffee Seminar Sep, Oct and Nov 2017

New Capital Allowances CPD Seminar Dates

Cabot_Square,_Canary_Wharf_-_June_2008

Pension Funds and Capital Allowances Interactions

lexis

Lexis Nexis Webinar – Capital Allowances in 2017

Lovell Coffee Seminar May and June 2017

New Capital Allowances CPD Seminar Date & Speakers Announced

Kaca_film_40%

Capital Allowances and Demountable Partitions; To Move or Not to Move?

1966_Sunliner_caravan_(6262976143)

Employees Claiming Capital Allowances: Caravan Case Demonstrates Hurdles!

Midland_Hotel,_Morecambe,_Lancashire,_England-31Aug2010_(3)

Capital Allowances, Corporation Tax Loss Relief & Interest Deductions – Act Now

British_Houses_of_Parliament

Corporation Tax Loss Relief & Interest Deductions: Capital Allowances

Bar

New 2017 Capital Allowances CPD Seminar Dates Announced

1872042_8c5756ec

Capital Allowances, Trustees and Tax Havens

buildings-1245684_960_720

Interview: A Little Capital Allowances Knowledge Can Be Dangerous

3638890517_7161f4c331_z

MBL Seminar Dates Announced (Capital Allowances in Retail, Hospitality & Offices)

new-picture-56

2016 Lovell Consulting Capital Allowances Art Prize Voting Begins

1

Capital Allowances in the Retail Sector

Palm with a plant growng from pile of coins

Free Cash, Tax Savings & Capital Allowances for SMEs Going Green

2276927_4f106630

Student Accommodation & Capital Allowances

blake-h-portrait

Lovell Consulting Capital Allowances Student Prize Winner 2016

pexels-photo

Capital Allowances within Offices

MBL Webinar

MBL Webinar – Capital Allowances for Property Surveyors

2414578731_82c451232d_b

Capital Allowances & Data Centres

taxjournal-logo

Tax Journal Interview: One minute with…John Lovell, Capital Allowances Specialist

Odeon_Barnet,_High_Barnet,_EN5_(4497059063)

Claiming Capital Allowances and / or Repairs

york-united-kingdom-empty-street

Commercial Property Standard Enquiries: Capital Allowances

New Picture (54)

LexisNexis Webinar – Tax for General Practice & Capital Allowances

New Picture (44)

LexisNexis Webinar – Commercial Property Law & Capital Allowances

Thumbs_up_bluefilter

New Capital Allowances Team Appointment – Glenn Ramos

New Picture (48)

MBL Webinar for Property Lawyers and Tax Advisers (Capital Allowances)

Gherkin_stitch

Fundamental Changes to Interest Deductions & Impact for Capital Allowances

playground-99509_960_720 - Copy

Capital Allowances within Childcare Facilities & Schools

Royal_Coat_of_Arms_of_the_United_Kingdom_(HM_Government).svg

John Lovell Comments: 2016 Budget – Impact on Capital Allowances: Commercial Property

Thumbs_up_bluefilter

Capital Allowances Team Announcements

MamaMarseille

Better Call Lovell for Capital Allowances

0928aa_ee33b990a61e441d83d6b257a590d366

Lovell Consulting Capital Allowances 2015 Art Prize

Lexis

LexisNexis Capital Allowances Webinar with John Lovell & Ronak Shah

x-default

Plant in Garden Centres: Claiming the Right Kind for Capital Allowances

1280px-Serpentine_Gallery_Pavilion_5_(2732918169)

Can an Accountant Claim the Capital Allowances without Specialist Support ?

New Picture (33)b

John Lovell Capital Allowances talk at Chartered Institute of Taxation Conference

Albert_dock_at_night

Enterprise Zones & Capital Allowances

14228109324_186f38de00_o

Capital Allowances & Landlord Contributions to Tenant Fitting Out Works

wall-of-keys

10 Key Qualities To Look For In A Capital Allowances Advisor

aMaiFZY

Capital Allowances within Private Member Clubs

iStock_000005218304Small

Effective Dealing with HMRC for Capital Allowances

Taxation Feedback Article

Taxation Feedback: Capital Allowances

rooms+cover

Capital Allowances within Restaurants

Poole2-VTerraceC

Capital Allowances within Nursing Homes

Little Book

Little Book of Big Capital Allowances Savings

xglobal-REIT-ETF.jpg.pagespeed.ic.U54haEqpZd

Real Estate Investment Trusts: Get The REIT Advice on Capital Allowances

Siemens-6MW-Wind-Turbine

Wind Turbines and Capital Allowances

cont land

Contaminated Land – The Big Clean Up for Capital Allowances

New Picture (20)

Capital Allowances & Furnished Holiday Lets

CT_Lobby_01-of5a411

Capital Allowances Hidden Gems within Hotels

tax_1815371c

Helpful Tips for Claiming Capital Allowances in Tax Returns

Tax-question_300_2

Why Do I Need A Capital Allowances Specialist?

seedling

Land Remediation Relief & Capital Allowances Q&A

Inspired Capital Allowances Savings_Page_1

Inspired Capital Allowances Savings

580_Image_homes_new_oldham

Private Rented Sector (PRS) & Capital Allowances: Key Planning Points

london-6

Drafting For Purchase Contracts And CPSE Capital Allowances Responses

The Great Hall, University of Reading

Lovell Consulting Capital Allowances Student Prize Winner 2015

George Osborne Summer Budget 2015

Summer Budget 2015: Property Tax Updates & Impact for Capital Allowances

???????????????????????????????

The Benefits of Claiming Annual Investment Allowances

LN

Lawyers Should Seek Specialist Capital Allowances Advice

Lovell_Consulting_Groups22-1500w

The New Environment For Capital Allowances

Capital Allowances demolition costs

Capital Allowances – Demolition Costs

Capital Allowances - Asbestos Removal

Capital Allowances – Asbestos Removal

wooden-judges-gavel-1024x678 (2)

Capital Allowances Case Summary: Bowerswood House Retirement Home

wooden-judges-gavel-1024x678 (2)

Property Tax Case Summary: Terrace Hill (Berkeley) Ltd: Impact for Capital Allowances

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

Business Premises Renovation Allowance (BPRA) Case Summary: Senex Investments

Construction Expenditure image

Capital Allowances Savings for Construction Expenditure

58767673

Recent Capital Allowances Case Study

wooden-judges-gavel-1024x678 (2)

Capital Allowances Case Summary – Rogate Services

crest(300x380)

Lovell Consulting Capital Allowances Student Prize Winner

wooden-judges-gavel-1024x678 (2)

Capital Allowances Case Summary – LLPs and AIA

Kirsty and Mike 2

New Capital Allowances Team Members

See Saw 2-10 (2)

Lovell Consulting Capital Allowances 2014 Art Prize

EGA_030514_301.indd

Recent Lovell Consulting Press Coverage: Capital Allowances

Lovell_Consulting_Groups05

April 2014 Capital Allowances Fixtures Rules

budgetbox_1107228c

The Budget of 19 March 2014 Announced a Number of Capital Allowances Changes

Lovell_Consulting_Groups22-1500w

Capital Allowances Case Update – The Granleys

Holiday Lets 2

Capital Allowances on Furnished Holiday Lets

wetherspoons-woking-01

Capital Allowances Case Update – Wetherspoon

budgetbox_1107228c

The Budget of 23 March 2012 Announced a Number of Capital Allowances Changes